Can the use of torture ever be justified introduction this report aims to, in the first instance, define torture it then examines the history of torture and looks at international law that relates to torture. Torturing the terrorist is unethical and can't be justified, but it can be understood, and it can be forgiven torturing the terrorist is unethical, but in those circumstances it is the 'right. Can torture ever be justified as part of the perspectives series, bbc religion and ethics asked two contributors to bbc one's religious debate programme the. To demonstrate just how abstract the torments of the tortured can be made to seem, we need only imagine an ideal torture pill--a drug that would deliver both the instruments of torture. 'torture report': did harsh interrogations help find osama bin laden knowledge issue can it be justified to torture a human being as an interrogation method, if the person holds relevant information that could save lives.
I was not sure torture could ever be justified - i accepted that it happened, but was never comfortable trying to justify it i have to say that now, having seen this movie, i think torture can, and must at times be justified. Clip from the 3/1/15 episode of the reason (religiously educated atheists secularists and other non-theists) secular roundtable discussion regarding the use. Don't let arguments for torture go unchallenged watch this video where former us president carter, the un special rapporteur on torture and others raise the.
Can the use of torture be justified officially a thing of the dark ages, torture is still used today many prisoners of war are tortured for information, as are suspects in malicious crimes yet, according to the geneva conventions, “torture, cruel or inhuman treatment and. Torture is not used to extract information it is used as a deterrant confessions obtained under torture are deemed to be 'unsafe' and are frequently subsequently retracted, should the survivor be lucky enough to survive and a case comes before a court of law surely, those who practice torture are worse, or certainly no better than those they torture. To make prior judgment that torture is justified in some circumstances is dangerous and wrong – torture must be prosecuted as a crime wherever it occurs however, it is also important to recognize the mitigating circumstances when it occurs.
Torture by all means is wrong i don't know what justification can be given to using the awareness of a human to inflict pain and suffering on another human. Many readers have responded, with questions and criticisms, to my argument last week that “regardless of circumstances or results, torture can never be justified” let me respond to some of. A majority of americans think that the harsh interrogation techniques used on terrorism suspects after the sept 11, 2001, attacks were justified, even as about half of the public says the. In october 2006, president george w bush said that the united states doesn't torture, and isn't going to torture three and a half years earlier, in march 2003, the bush administration had secretly tortured khalid sheikh mohammed 183 times in a single month. Home » crime library » execution » can torture be justified the united nations 1984 convention against torture prohibits any acts of torture including cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment and is an international human rights law.
The basic ethical debate is often presented as a matter of deontological versus utilitarian viewpoint a utilitarian thinker may believe, when the overall outcome of lives saved due to torture are positive, torture can be justified the intended outcome of an action is held as the primary factor in determining its merit or morality. Hooded men: can the use of torture by a state be justified in legal philosophy, there are two main sides to the torture debate, writes conor courtney. For any purpose, however, torture has never been able to be justified, at any point in our history and most definitely will not be at any point in our future torture is often useless many claim that torture can be justified because it comes down to the safety of the people. Is torture justified 1704 words | 7 pages composition i november 9, 2013 is torture justified what is torture basically, this is the action of physically or psychologically hurting a person without their permission and against their will.
Can torture, the infliction of intolerable pain to extract potentially life-saving information from war criminals, ever be justified what if this torture or activity is sanctioned or. Immanuel kant was a german philosopher and rationalist on the 18th century he was an exponent of an absolutist ethical theory known as kantian ethics. But does that mean that torture can sometimes be justified to extract information get our daily newsletter upgrade your inbox and get our daily dispatch and editor's picks.
Is torture ever justified in a post-9/11 world frontline gathered a group of legal thinkers to answer this question several of them had studied the torture question together for a joint project. Torture 고문 justify 정당화하다 officially a thing of the dark ages, torture is still used today many prisoners of war are tortured for information, as are sus can the use of torture be justified. Can torture be justified zero dark thirty is a 2012 film that has been billed as the story of history's greatest manhunt for the world's most dangerous man it is a dramatization of the american operation that killed osama bin laden.
To torture a human is ethically wrong but it can be understandable under certain circumstances 4 sometimes we need to place ourselves in the other end before making a quick decision whether torture can be justified or not. Torture can never be justified, under article 3 of the european convention on human rights there is a complete prohibition on torture there is nothing in that article that allows for this right to be violated unlike other articles in the convention eg privacy which can. The number of americans saying the use of torture against suspected terrorists is at least sometimes justified has been fairly stable since 2004, though the percentage saying torture can often be justified has dipped from 18% in october 2006.